I realize the 12-year-olds in my class are not committing murder or smoking or doing anything really bad. They are good kids. I may not have prepared my lesson as best as I could, but they really took me off guard yesterday. Here’s a rundown of my class yesterday (it’s kind of long):
(I’ll call the class Mary, Sarah, Elizabeth, and John, just for privacy’s sake.)
We started by reading Alma 38:8. Mary had forgotten her scriptures. Our meeting house library only has spare scriptures in Chinese.
- Me: Alma had to recognize he’s sinned: he felt the pain of guilt. The first part of repentance is recognizing you did something wrong. Why do you think we need to recognize that?
- Sarah: So you can repent. Duh! Ew! Stop–that is so gross.
- [Mary has taken a pushpin from the bulletin board and is popping the blister on her toe with it. I decide to ignore her. Why? I don't know.]
- Me: Ok, let’s read Doctrine and Covenants 58:38. John, can you read that?
- Sarah: Ew! Now I need to wash my foot! [She storms out of the room.]
- Elizabeth: What happened? [That's what I'm thinking too.]
- Mary: I bumped her foot with mine! [I don't blame Sarah at this point: Mary has been popping blisters on her toe. I would want to wash my foot too.]
- Me: OK, so what those verses said: What do we need to do to repent?
- Elizabeth: Confess and Forsake.
- Me: Good!Can you write that on the board? [Elizabeth volunteered before class to be scribe.]
- Mary: You dummy! Confess has two S‘s.
- Me: Let’s not call names. It doesn’t matter how it’s spelled. What does forsake mean?
- Mary: It means, well, like “For your sake.”
- Me: Not quite. It means “to give up.” Why do you think we need to give up our sins?
- John: So we don’t do it again. To show we’re sorry and won’t do it again.
- Me, glad someone is focused: Right. To show we won’t do it again: we really mean it! Another thing we have to do is keep the commandments. (Can you write that on the board, too?)
- [Elizabeth has by now drawn an elaborate design beside the list of steps of repentance. She's also written CTR! CHOOSE TO REPENT!]
- Elizabeth: Oh, what am I suppose to write?
- [Great, has she heard any of this?]
- John: Keep the commandments!
- Sarah, storming back into the room: That was the grossest thing in the world!
- Me: Anyway, as I was saying. We need to not do it again. So if we’re sorry we hit our sister and we’re repenting for doing that, we need to not do it again.
- Sarah: Well, except, some things we will do again. Like, I know I’ll hit my brother again.
- Me: Well, if we are sincere in wanting to repent, we need to stop doing it.
- Elizabeth: But I have to hit my sisters!
- Me: Remember how we talked about the premortal life where Satan wanted to let us return to Heavenly Father but he wouldn’t give us a choice? Instead, we came to earth under Heavenly Father’s plan with Christ as our Savior, so what did Heavenly Father give us?
- Elizabeth: Our agency!
- Me: Exactly! So you can choose not to hit your brother.
- Elizabeth: No, I can’t.
- Sarah: I have to hit my brothers.
- Mary: There is no choice in the matter.
- John: I don’t hit my brother.
- Mary: You only have one brother.
- Sarah: Yeah, I have six siblings. I have to defend myself.
- [Sarah has five siblings. I correct her and she says, no, her dad counts as a sibling. Great.]
- Elizabeth: I have to fight.
- Sarah: Ew! Stop it! That’s gross. [Mary has renewed the pushpin technique. Now she's pricking her fingers.]
- Me: Mary, will you stop poking yourself with a pushpin?!
- [Mary puts the pushpin back into the board and sits and sulks.]
- Me, to Elizabeth: Well, if your brother is mean to you, what choices do you have?
- Elizabeth: To defend myself.
- Me: And what other choice?
- Elizabeth: To defend myself.
- Me: And…
- Elizabeth: To fight.
- Me: You can choose not to fight.
- Elizabeth: No, they’ll all say “What’s wrong with you?”
- Sarah: Right. I have to defend myself.
- Me: Ok, so anyway, Heavenly Father’s plan is that we repent and that we actually feel sorry when we repent.
We also talked about making restitution (apologizing, making up for what was wrong) after we do something and we read some more scriptures, but I couldn’t get them to stop claiming they must fight with their siblings. They don’t believe me when I say they have a choice. I couldn’t get Mary to participate after I called her off of her disgusting pop-the-blister kick.
Now, I know I fought with my sister. But I know I chose to fight with her. I know when I still argue with people that I’m choosing to argue. It’s my fault just as much as anyone else’s. It takes two to fight. I also think family discipline has something to do with it. I know Sarah’s family — they are a bit violent to each other in church; I can’t imagine how they would be at home. Case in point: John, who claims he doesn’t fight with his older brother, is a perfect, focused class-participant (most Sundays).
I really don’t remember what was like being twelve. I asked my husband what I can do. His answer? Don’t teach twelve-year-olds.
Here are my questions for you:
- Are all twelve-year-olds determined to fight with their siblings?
- How do I emphasize repentance when they think they have no choice in the matter (other than using a better example)?
- Also, when a class member is being distracting and popping blisters or being gross, how do I ask her to stop without making her annoyed and sullen the rest of the class?
Lesson 12 of 45

![100_28242[1]](http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7032/6692660549_8285875ede_m.jpg)
![100_28251[1]](http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7021/6692661169_c9662f9548_m.jpg)